Historically Low San Luis Reservoir Highlights Broken Water System

  • by Timothy Quinn
  • Aug 17, 2016
  • Voices on Water

If you need a sign that the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta is broken, look no further than San Luis Reservoir. Despite near-average precipitation this year and healthy storage in other north state reservoirs, San Luis is so precipitously low that deliveries were nearly shutoff in early August.

Meanwhile Shasta Lake, the state’s largest reservoir, sits at 109% of its historic average for the date.

What’s wrong with this picture? In a nutshell, we have a water system that is broken from a physical and policy standpoint.

Recent developments illustrate the problem. Earlier this year, during the El Niño storms that provided at least some respite from the drought, federal officials over-cautiously kept pumping levels very low to protect Delta smelt, which prevented water from being delivered for storage in San Luis and later to farms and cities south of the Delta.  Not long after that, other federal officials decided to reserve significant volumes of water in Shasta this summer to keep it cold for winter-run salmon. Their plan restricted releases into the Sacramento River so much that some growers were at risk of supply disruptions. Delta salinity problems exacerbated by the low flows made it extremely difficult to move water into San Luis, to the point that the Bureau of Reclamation exhausted its share of stored water in the reservoir and struggled to maintain even minimal deliveries to agricultural water users south of the Delta. Algae problems in the low reservoir are creating water quality challenges for urban users in the Santa Clara Valley that rely on San Luis.

This scenario underscores the peril of regulatory agencies focusing almost exclusively on species protection at the expense of water supply.  Moreover, efforts to protect endangered fish virtually always narrowly focus on a single element – temperature control or flows – while failing to address other important factors affecting the species. Allowing a single-stressor approach to drive water management decisions only serves to maximize conflict between species protection and water supply, while failing to adequately serve either. And we continue to lose water supply every day as a result.

No one wants to see the demise of fish species. In fact, the water community is demonstrating quite the opposite with major investments by several water agencies to improve habitat and fish passage for salmon populations. Through the Salmon Recovery Program, funded in large part by water agencies, more than 200,000 tons of gravel has been deposited into waterways, improving salmon spawning ground. Fish screens also have been built to protect fish migrating up the river to spawn.  In recent decades, entire streams have been reconfigured using comprehensive management tools to provide habitat for salmon, while protecting the ability to provide reliable water supplies, sometimes with spectacular results.

Another bright spot is the Delta Smelt Resiliency Strategy released by the Brown Administration this summer. Though still relying on unproven flow elements (this time requiring increased flows during the summer months when they would never occur naturally), the strategy emphasizes multiple stressors and puts a comprehensive, lifecycle approach to saving Delta smelt on the table for the first time.

The water community strongly supports the California policy of coequal goals. Sadly, actions by regulatory agencies continue to undermine that policy. Any one driving past San Luis Reservoir this summer can see the result.

We need a comprehensive strategy for managing water supply and our aquatic resources if we are to achieve the coequal goals. Our environment, and our economy, can’t wait.


Executive Director Timothy Quinn may be reached at timq@acwa.com

Suggested Resources

15 RESOURCES prev next
Joint Response to Comments Related to 1,2,3-TCP MCL

Submitted to the State Water Resources Control Board on July 14, 2017.

Comments on ALJ Ruling to Modify D-17-01-006

Submitted to California Public Utilities Commission on July 11, 2017.

Federal Regulatory Chart

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Joint Comments on Water Audits / Water Loss Control Reporting Regulations

Submitted to the California Department of Water Resources on July 3, 2017.

Joint Comments on Perchlorate Reporting

Submitted to the State Water Resources Control Board on June 29, 2017.

Priority Issues Bulletin

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Comments on Process for Integrated Resources Planning

Submitted to the California Public Utilities Commission on June 28, 2017.

ACWA Brand Toolkits

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Comments on PSP For Groundwater Sustainability Plans and Projects

Submitted to the California Department of Water Resources on June 19, 2017.

ACWA Comments on “Waters of the United States”

Submitted to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on June 19, 2017

Public Water Agencies At Your Service

California’s public water agencies are committed to serving the public through transparent and locally-accountable management of the state’s water resources. […]

21st Century Water Infrastructure

This winter’s record-breaking rainfall and snowpack did more than end an historic five-year drought. It underscored the feast-or-famine nature of […]

Joint Letter in Response to DWR Resources Report

Submitted to California Natural Resources Agency, California Department of Food and Agriculture, and California Environmental Protection Agency on June 1, 2017

ACWA 2017 Spring Conference Presentations

Presentations from ACWA’s 2017 Spring Conference & Exhibition held May 9 – 12 in Monterey are available below. Please note that this […]

A Defining Moment in California Water

“A Defining Moment in California Water” highlights the need for a more balanced and comprehensive approach to setting water quality […]

Suggested News

15 Articles prev next
U.S. EPA Selects Projects Eligible to Apply for $2.3 Billion in WIFIA Loans

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has selected 12 water infrastructure projects in nine states to apply for $2.3 billion in […]

Former State Senator and Author of the Delta Reform Act Dave Cogdill Dies

Former state Sen. Dave Cogdill, who indelibly shaped California water policy by authoring and supporting the Delta Reform Act of […]

Laird Announces Formation of Climate-Safe Infrastructure Working Group

California Natural Resources Secretary John Laird today announced the appointment of 14 leaders in state climate science and infrastructure design […]

DWR Certifies Environmental Documents, Approves California WaterFix Under CEQA

The California Department of Water Resources today announced that it has certified the environmental analysis of California WaterFix and approved […]

ACWA NEWS: JULY 21, 2017

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Faces of Water Q&A – July 2017

Telling the stories of the people who work to deliver California’s water… 1.) Describe your job. I get to serve the […]

Member Case Study – July 2017

Butte Creek Fish Passage Improvement Project: 20 Years of Collaboration and Ingenuity Spring-run Chinook salmon have returned en masse to […]

ACWA Seeking Dedicated Committee Members for 2018-’19 Term

ACWA is currently accepting committee considerations for the 2018-’19 Term. Consideration forms are due Sept. 29, 2017. ACWA President Kathleen […]

SCWA’s Grant Davis Tapped to Lead Department of Water Resources

Gov. Jerry Brown has appointed Sonoma County Water Agency General Manager Grant Davis to serve as director of the California […]

State Water Board Adopts MCL for 1,2,3-TCP, Rejects Calls to Establish Compliance Period

The State Water Resources Control Board on July 18 adopted a regulation establishing a maximum contaminant level (MCL) for 1,2,3,-Trichloropropane […]

What Lessons Can Butte Creek Teach Us About Improving Fisheries in California?

There is a spectacular success story in Northern California that proves that the coequal goals are attainable and multi-agency collaboration […]

David van Rijn Selected as Planning Officer for Reclamation’s Mid-Pacific Region

The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation’s Mid-Pacific Region today announced the selection of David van Rijn as the region’s new planning […]

OCWD Helps Guide State Effort to Improve Operation of Wastewater Treatment Plants

FOUNTAIN VALLEY, Calif. (July 13, 2017) – Orange County Water District (OCWD; the District) Operations Manager Tyson Neely was appointed […]

GROW Act Passes House

The House, on Wednesday, passed a drought bill sponsored by U.S. Rep. David Valadao (R-CA). The bill, HR 23, the […]

Scaled-Down Conservation Bills Clear Senate Committee; Work to Continue over Recess

The Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee stripped two conservation bills down to intent language and passed a third in […]