ACWA Weighs in on State Water Affordability Legislation

  • by Dave Eggerton
  • Mar 19, 2021
  • Voices on Water

ACWA and its member agencies care greatly about water affordability and recognize the centrality of this issue during these uniquely challenging times. ACWA is advocating in Washington, D.C. (already with some success) and in Sacramento for federal and state funding to help public water systems and treatment works cover customer arrearages accrued during the pandemic. This funding is needed quickly — through immediate action — as opposed to through the legislative process for long-term policy bills. 

Two state policy bills introduced this year and related to water affordability are well-intended  but contain fundamental flaws that would make the measures counterproductive. 

Sen. Bill Dodd (D-Napa) is the author of companion bills SB 222 and SB 223. At ACWA’s March 11 virtual Legislative Symposium, Dodd indicated that he is willing to work with ACWA on the bills. Work to resolve the issues is critical. The first bill, SB 222, would require the State Water Resources Control Board to create an overly broad and costly water and wastewater affordability program with many components, implemented in part by roughly 2,900 public water systems. ACWA has an oppose-unless-amended position and is suggesting, with detailed amendments, that the bill propose one major program – a water and wastewater low-income water rate assistance program. The state should build on an existing low-income financial assistance program, such as CalFresh and the California Food Assistance Program, as opposed to reinventing the wheel. This approach would help low-income households across the state and have much lower administrative costs. 

Meanwhile, the second bill, SB 223, would require public water systems to forgive the entire balance of a customer’s unpaid water debt if the customer enters into an arrearage management plan.  A proposal for a mandate for full or partial water debt forgiveness by public water agencies would be illegal under the state Constitution. Under Proposition 218, public water agencies cannot legally use revenue from some of its customers to subsidize the cost of service for other customers. 

In addition to being illegal, the proposal would harm the financial stability of public water agencies and, in doing so, would jeopardize their ability to provide safe drinking water to all customers, comply with other regulatory requirements and replace aging infrastructure. 

SB 223 would also re-write the restrictions on discontinuation of residential water service that were put into place by the enactment of SB 998 in 2018, also authored by Dodd. ACWA agrees with Dodd that the conditions on discontinuation of service are important. Also important is the communication between systems and their customers regarding plans for payment. ACWA member agencies have a long history of working with their customers who struggle to pay their bills by creating payment plans.

SB 998, and its new conditions on discontinuation of service, went into full effect in early February of 2020 – two months before Governor Newsom issued the executive order that suspended the authority for discontinuation of service during the pandemic. The reality is that SB 998 has only been in full effect for two months. The Legislature should give that law time to work. ACWA is agreeing to address issues that were not addressed in SB 998 (e.g., expand its scope to smaller systems and work to add reasonable provisions regarding emergency situations, such as a pandemic).

ACWA is making the case to the author, Legislature and sponsors as to why the introduced versions of the bill are problematic. Between now and when the bills are heard in committee in April, ACWA will also work with the author and sponsors on amendments to improve affordability in an effective, efficient, legal and sustainable way.

Suggested Resources

15 RESOURCES prev next
Comment Letter: Lead and Copper Rule Revisions

Agency: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Subject: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s National Primary Drinking Water Regulations: Lead and Copper Rule Revisions; Delay […]

Coalition Letter: SB 222 – Water Rate Assistance Program

To: Honorable Ben Hueso, Chair, Senate Committee on Energy, Utilities, and Communications Subject: SB 222 (Dodd) – Water Rate Assistance […]

Coalition Letter: SB 223 – Discontinuation of Residential Water Service

To: Honorable Ben Hueso, Chair, Senate Committee on Energy, Utilities, and Communications Subject: SB 223 (Dodd) – Discontinuation of Residential […]

Coalition Letter: Advanced Clean Fleets Workshop

Agency: California Air Resources Board Subject: Coalition Comments on the March 2nd and 4th, 2021 Advanced Clean Fleets Workshops Letter excerpt: […]

Coalition Letter: Biden Infrastructure Proposal

Subject: National Ag, Water Coalition Highlights Need for More Water Investments in Biden Infrastructure Proposal Letter excerpt: Recognizing the constructive […]

Comment Letter: Water Rights Climate Change Report

Agency: State Water Resources Control Board Subject: ACWA Comments on Water Rights Climate Change Report Letter excerpt: The Association of California Water […]

Joint Letter: American Rescue Plan

To: The Honorable Janet Yellen Subject: American Rescue Plan Treasury Guidance Letter excerpt: Our nation’s water providers appreciate your strong leadership on […]

Coalition Letter: Proposed Clean Fleets Rule

Agency: California Air Resources Board Subject: Association of California Water Agencies and California Association of Sanitation Agencies Comments on Proposed Clean […]

Toolkit to Help Members with Drought Messaging

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Proposed Advanced Clean Fleets Regulation

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Coalition Letter: Long-Term Water Affordability Program

To: Speaker Pelosi, Minority Leader McCarthy, Senators Feinstein and Padilla, and Members of the California Congressional Delegation Subject: Include Urgently […]

Comment Letter: Support for Wildfire and Forest Resilience Action Plan

Agency: California Natural Resources Agency Subject: Support for Governor Newsom’s Wildfire and Forest Resilience Action Plan and Agreement for Shared Stewardship […]

Comment Letter: Gap Analysis for Funding Solutions for Human Right to Water and At-Risk Drinking Water Systems

Agency: State Water Resources Control Board Subject: ACWA and CMUA Comments regarding the Draft White Paper Discussion On: Gap Analysis for […]

Comment Letter: SB 45 (Portantino) Bond Act of 2022

To: The Honorable Henry Stern Subject: SB 45 (Portantino): The Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection […]

Position Letter: SB 223 (Dodd) – Discontinuation of Residential Water Service for Nonpayment

To: Chair, Senate Committee on Energy, Utilities, and Communications Subject: SB 223 (Dodd) – Discontinuation of Residential Water Service for Nonpayment Position: Oppose […]

Suggested News

15 Articles prev next
Governor Issues Drought State of Emergency Proclamation

Gov. Newsom today proclaimed a drought emergency in Sonoma and Mendocino counties, noting the severe conditions in the Russian River […]

Joe Mouawad Selected as EMWD General Manager

PERRIS — Eastern Municipal Water District’s (EMWD) Board of Directors today selected Joe Mouawad as EMWD’s next General Manager following […]

Newsom Provides Emergency Drought Assistance to Russian River Watershed

Sonoma County Water Agency (Sonoma Water) joined Governor Newsom today at a parched Lake Mendocino for the announcement of an […]

ACWD Awarded $2 Million For Tri-City Water Conservation Efforts

Alameda County Water District has received a $2 million grant from the Bureau of Reclamation for its Advanced Metering Infrastructure […]

Virtual Coffee with Director Wilson on April 27

PALMDALE –  Palmdale Water District (PWD) Board Director Don Wilson will be featured at this month’s Virtual Coffee with a […]

April Priority Issues Update Available

The April 2021 Priority Issues Update is now available online to members. The update is a summary of the latest […]

IEUA and City of Chino Partner for Virtual Earth Day Event

CHINO – The Inland Empire Utilities Agency (IEUA) and the City of Chino will be hosting a virtual Earth Day […]

ACWA Testifies in Opposition of SB 222, SB 223

ACWA staff testified with an oppose-unless-amended position on SB 222 (Dodd) and an oppose position on SB 223 (Dodd) during […]

Ed Stevenson Announced as Alameda County Water District’s New GM

Alameda County Water District Board of Directors announced during the April 13 Board meeting the appointment of Ed Stevenson as […]

FEMA Awards Rancho Water $1 Million for New Electrical Generators

TEMECULA – The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) has awarded a grant for $1 million to the Rancho California Water […]

ACWA Launches Member Innovation Webpage

ACWA has launched a new innovation webpage – – to promote member agencies’ innovative programs, practices, technologies and more. […]

ACWA Testifies in Support of Climate Resilience Bond Proposal with Amendments

ACWA staff testified with a support-if-amended position on AB 1500 (E.Garcia) during an Assembly Water, Parks and Wildlife Committee hearing […]

Save Our Water Offers Water Agencies Bilingual Communications Toolkit

The Save Our Water program recently launched newly designed English and Spanish websites at and an easy-to-access partner toolkit […]

EPA Lead and Copper Rule Comments Due April 12

A 30-day public comment period on the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s revised Lead and Copper Rule (LCR) ends April 12. […]

Roseville transforms courtyard garden into a water wise inspiration

Rain or shine, water efficiency in California is a way of life. That’s why the City of Roseville has embarked […]