What ‘Collaboration Over Conflict’ Can Look Like

  • by Dave Eggerton
  • Dec 26, 2018
  • Voices on Water

The Dec. 12 decision by the State Water Resources Control Board came with a silver lining. Yes, its 4-1 vote to move forward with a regulatory approach to relying on a percentage of unimpaired flows was disappointing. But in arriving at that decision, State Water Board members heard the most compelling argument yet for considering an alternative approach, one that relies on collaboration among water stakeholders to achieve the same result, and likely with better outcomes.

Thanks to leadership and engagement by Gov. Jerry Brown, and because of a comprehensive presentation by Department of Water Resources Director Karla Nemeth and Department of Fish and Wildlife Director Chuck Bonham, Californians now have a much more clear understanding of the investment, dedication and collaborative work among water agencies through voluntary settlement agreements. And just as importantly, the State Water Board left the door open for further consideration of voluntary settlement agreements.

The one in front of them Dec. 12 encompassed 14 signatories spanning seven watersheds, including the Tuolumne River, between the Sacramento River and the Lower San Joaquin River. You can view by visiting DWR online at www.water.ca.gov. It would invest $1.7 billion into habitat restoration to strengthen salmon runs while applying precise use of functional flows to make as much water available as possible to support the fishery. Some of its habitat restoration work is shovel ready for 2019. At least from my perspective, it embraced a far more sophisticated and well-thought-out strategy than employing a percentage of unimpaired flows as a one-dimensional panacea.

The revised version of the State Water Board’s Bay-Delta Plan moves toward mandating 40% of unimpaired flows for February through June, with an allowed adaptive range between 30% to 50% for the Stanislaus, Tuolumne and Merced rivers through to the San Joaquin River. This will likely initiate a lengthy water rights process. While increasing flows for the protection of the Delta ecosystem and salmon runs, the amendment will drastically reduce water available to water users in the Lower San Joaquin River Watershed. We all know it does not have to be this way to attain the coequal goals in state law of improving the Bay-Delta ecosystem and water supply reliability. But at least we now have time to demonstrate that, with State Water Board Chair Felicia Marcus acknowledging that voluntary settlement agreements have potential and deserve a closer look. That might happen as early as next March.

In the meantime, the voluntary settlement agreements presented Dec. 12 went beyond the initial phase under consideration by including the Sacramento River. Framework documents released for a second phase in the State Water Board’s process to update the Bay-Delta Plan currently indicates the setting of a 55% unimpaired flow requirement in the Sacramento Valley.

What could still happen – and we’re a big step closer to this after Dec. 12 – is the Central Valley irrigation districts and other stakeholders understandably feeling that they may have no other recourse than the courts. But the good news is, the details behind how a collaborative process can bring meaningful benefits to the Delta and its tributaries are no longer obscured or exist in bits and pieces. The comprehensive presentation put forth by Nemeth and Bonham, backed by Gov. Brown and reflecting nonstop hard work by participating water agencies, is there for all to see, understand and appreciate.

The work of all of us now is to support the collaborative process behind voluntary settlement agreements we saw presented on Dec. 12. The many people who worked on them deserve our respect, and we all deserve to see their hard work achieve its full potential.

Suggested Resources

15 RESOURCES prev next
Webinar: COVID-19 Series – The Great Re-Set: Leading the Workplace Post COVID-19

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Comment Letter: Request for Water Infrastructure Funding in Future COVID-19 Legislation

To: Majority Leader McConnell, Minority Leader Schumer, Speaker Pelosi and Minority Leader McCarthy Subject: ACWA Request for Water Infrastructure Funding […]

Coalition Letter: Funding for Water Infrastructure and Water Affordability in Response to COVID-19

To: Speaker Pelosi, Minority Leader McCarthy, Senators Feinstein and Harris, and Members of the California Congressional Delegation Subject: Include Urgently […]

Comment Letter: Draft Fund Expenditure Plan for the Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Fund

Agency: State Water Resource Control Board Subject: Comment Letter – Draft Fund Expenditure Plan for the Safe and Affordable Drinking […]

Comment Letter: Water Loss Regulation

To: Ms. Jeanine Townsend Subject: Comment Letter – Water Loss Regulation Webinar Letter excerpt: The coalition of organizations listed below […]

Webinar: Geohazard Mitigation for California Water Agencies

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Coalition Letter: Regulation of PFOS, PFOA and other PFAS in Drinking Water

To: The Honorable Andrew Wheeler Subject: Regulation of PFOS, PFOA and other PFAS in drinking water Letter excerpt: We appreciate the […]

Comment Letter: Proposed Decision Adopting Additional and Modified De-Energization Guidelines

Agency: California Public Utilities Commission Subject: Joint Comments of Valley Center Municipal Water District, Padre Dam Municipal Water District, Municipal Water […]

Comment Letter: White Paper Discussion on Economic Feasibility Analysis in Consideration of a Hexavalent Chromium MCL

To: Jeanine Townsend, Clerk to the Board State Water Resources Control Board Subject: White Paper Discussion on Economic Feasibility Analysis […]

ACWA Submits Letters Urging State and Federal Leadership to Achieve Voluntary Agreements

To: Governor Newsom and U.S. Department of Interior Secretary Bernhardt Subject: Voluntary Agreements Description: ACWA urges Gov. Newsom and Secretary […]

Coalition Letter: Funding for Water Infrastructure & Affordability in Response to COVID-19 Pandemic

To: Speaker Pelosi, Minority Leader McCarthy and Members of the California Congressional Delegation: Subject: Include Urgently Needed Funding for Water […]

Webinar: How to Reduce Costs with PG&E’s New Time-of-Use (TOU) Rate Analysis

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Comment Letter: Draft Handbook for Water Budget Development

Agency: California Department of Water Resources Subject: Comment Letter on the ‘Draft Handbook for Water Budget Development: With or Without […]

Federal Regulatory Issues Chart

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

2019 Year in Review

Throughout 2019, ACWA advanced its policy goals by employing robust advocacy at the state and federal levels. Collaborative work with member […]

Suggested News

15 Articles prev next
BBID Uses World-Class Tech to Conduct Major Pipeline Test

BYRON – Using cutting-edge technology, Byron-Bethany Irrigation District (BBID or District) conducted a comprehensive condition assessment test of one of its […]

DWR Awards $11 Million in Grants for Fish Habitat Restoration & Enhancement Projects

SACRAMENTO – The Department of Water Resources (DWR) today awarded $11 million in grants to five projects that will improve the […]

DWR Announces $83.9 Million in Grants for Local and Regional Water Resilience Projects

SACRAMENTO – More than 30 ACWA member agencies were included in the third set of funding awards announced by the […]

$200,000 Grant Awarded for Groundwater Sustainability in Kings County

Kings River Conservation District (KRCD) and Geosyntec Consultants successfully obtained a $200,000 grant to support groundwater sustainability activities in the […]

Yuba Water Approves Nearly $14 Million in Grants and Loans

MARYSVILLE — Yuba Water Agency’s Board of Directors June 7 committed approximately $14 million in grants and loans for water […]

Water Board Adopts Safe & Affordable Drinking Water Fund Expenditure Plan

SACRAMENTO – The State Water Resources Control Board on July 7 unanimously adopted the Fiscal Year (FY) 2020-’21 Fund Expenditure […]

Congressional Report Details CVP Issues

The Congressional Research Service recently released a new report, “Central Valley Project: Issues and Legislation,” to provide policy and legal […]

Sacramento-Area Water Providers Awarded $8.74M for Climate Resiliency Projects

Sacramento-area water providers have been awarded $8.74 million in state grants to advance 11 projects to build water reliability in […]

DSRSD Honors Science Fair Winners from Dublin High

The Dublin San Ramon Services District was pleased to congratulate three Dublin High School students this week for their award […]

Western Appoints New Director to Division 1 Seat

RIVERSIDE – The Western Municipal Water District (Western) Board of Directors on Wednesday, July 1, 2020, announced the appointment of […]

MSWD Approves Map for Election by Division

On June 24, 2020, the Mission Springs Water District (MSWD) Board of Directors voted unanimously to adopt a final map […]

ACWA Produces Updated 2020 PSPS Toolkit for Members

ACWA recently produced an updated Public Safety Power Shutoff (PSPS) Toolkit as a resource to help member agencies prepare for […]

U.S. House Passes H.R. 2 – Moving Forward Act

WASHINGTON, D.C. – After a marathon virtual markup held by the House Transportation and Infrastructure, followed by days of debate […]

Desert Water Agency earns $425,000 in Grants for Grass Removal Program

Desert Water Agency (DWA) was awarded $425,000 from the California Department of Water Resources (DWR) and US Bureau of Reclamation […]

Western Adopts Biennial Budget, Postponing Rate Adjustments

RIVERSIDE – During its regularly scheduled Board of Directors meeting on Wednesday, June 17, 2020, Western Municipal Water District’s (Western) […]