ACWA and CMUA Proposal for a Safe Drinking Water Trust A statewide water tax is not the right approach ACWA and the California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA) are sponsoring SB 669 (Caballero) to create a Safe Drinking Water Trust. Instead of relying on a proposed statewide water tax, the Trust would be funded with General Fund dollars during a state budget surplus year. The net income from the Trust would create a durable funding source that will help community water systems in disadvantaged communities provide access to safe drinking water. Why is there a need for safe drinking water funding in California? Most Californians have access to safe drinking water, but some disadvantaged communities do not Lack of access to safe drinking water is a public health issue the state must address A funding gap exists for operations & maintenance (O&M) costs for community water systems that treat water In general, O&M costs cannot be financed using existing state and federal drinking water funding sources In some situations, consolidation of a community water system may be the most effective solution A financial solution is needed for O&M and consolidation costs in disadvantaged communities that can complement existing federal and state funding sources for capital costs. How would the ACWA/CMUA proposal for a Trust work? The Trust’s principal would be initially financed with a one-time infusion of General Fund dollars during a budget surplus year There is a record budget surplus for the 2019-2020 Fiscal Year, which makes it the perfect time to create and fund the Trust Funding the Trust via the General Fund serves as a progressive source of revenue, as taxpayers with higher income would contribute more, while lower income taxpayers would contribute less The Trust’s principal would be invested, and the net income would be transferred to a Safe Drinking Water Fund, which the State Water Board would administer Why is a statewide water tax not the right approach? It isn’t sound policy to tax a resource that is essential to life A regressive statewide tax on local water bills is in conflict with keeping water affordable for all Californians It would be highly inefficient to require more than 3,000 local water agencies to serve as tax collectors for the state The combined local administrative costs would exceed the combined statewide water tax revenue collected with local water bills Broad Support for SB 669 – Safe Drinking Water Trust The following 100 agencies have indicated their support of SB 669. This list is current as of May 10, 2019. AGENCIES IN SUPPORT OF SB 669 Recent Events On Jan. 10, 2019, Gov. Gavin Newsom released his proposed budget for Fiscal Year 2019-’20 that includes a proposal for a Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Fund. Revenue for the fund would be collected through a statewide tax on drinking water and assessments on fertilizer sales and confined animal operations. Assembly Member Eduardo Garcia is the author of a legislative bill that contains a proposed water tax. AB 217 (E. Garcia) passed out of the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee on March 26 and is headed to the Assembly Appropriations Committee. The bill was most recently amended on March 28, and now proposes that a 50-cent “fee” be assessed annually on each service connection for all public water systems. Public water systems would be required to remit to the State Water Board the amount of the “fee” for that system. For example, a public water system with 250,000 service connections would pay an annual “fee” of $125,000. In addition to this water tax, the bill proposes agricultural assessments similar to those proposed in Gov. Brown’s proposed budget trailer bill language in 2018. These would be assessments on the sale of fertilizers and on confined animal operations. It also proposes a modified version of ACWA’s proposed Safe Drinking Water Trust (The Trust was intended to be a better alternative to water tax proposals). Finally, it proposes an authority to allocate up to 20% of the safe drinking water funds received back to the region of the state in which they were generated. In 2018, despite attempts to create a new water tax, the Legislature’s Budget Conference Committee rejected the statewide water tax proposed in the 2018 budget trailer bill and acted to include more than $25 million in General Fund revenue for safe drinking water in the 2018-2019 Fiscal Year State Budget. Also in 2018, California voters approved Proposition 68 with $250 million for safe drinking water and clean water projects that is prioritized for disadvantaged communities. Learn more about the previously proposed tax on drinking water. Californians Oppose a Drinking Water Tax Tulchin Research conducted a statewide poll in early 2018 based on a previous drinking water tax proposal. That poll showed that 73% of likely voters oppose a new tax on drinking water, both initially and even after hearing more information. Additionally, 74% would prefer using existing funding sources rather than establishing a new tax on drinking water. For more on the polling, please read the polling results memo or see our news release. Tools & Resources Safe Drinking Water Trust Toolkit (Feb. 2019, ACWA member login required) Safe Drinking Water Fund Legislative Proposal Fact Sheet (Feb. 2019) FAQs on Proposal to Tax Californians’ Drinking Water (Aug. 2018) Fact Sheet on Proposal to Tax Californians’ Drinking Water (Aug. 2018) Solve It Without a Drinking Water tax graphic WaterTaxFacts.org Water Tax Facts graphic 2019 ACWA & Coalition Letters Coalition Letter to Assembly Appropriations Committee: Oppose Unless Amended on AB 217 (E. Garcia): Safe Drinking Water Funding/Water Tax – May 3, 2019 ACWA Letter to Assembly Environmental Safety & Toxic Materials: Oppose Unless Amended on AB 217 (E. Garcia): Safe Drinking Water Funding/Water Tax – March 25, 2019 Coalition Letter to Senate Budget Subcommittee No. 2 and Assembly Budget Subcommittee No. 3: Oppose Water Tax Budget Trailer Bill Language – March 13, 2019 2019 Media Coverage What’s All This About a Water Tax? – New York Times – 5/13/19 Editorial: Gov. Newsom: Don’t Tax Life Essentials. But Tax Water. Huh? – San Diego Union Tribune – 5/8/19 Ignoring $30B from Water Bonds and State Surplus, Gov. Gavin Newsom Wants New Water Tax – California Globe – 3/21/19 Gov. Newsom Wants to Charge You $10 a Month to Help Clean Up Contaminated Water – ABC 7 – 3/21/19 California’s Proposed Affordable Drinking Water Fund Could Cost Residents up to $120 a year – yourcentralvalley.com – 3/21/19 Details of Newsom’s Plan for Drinking Water Tax Revealed – SF Gate – 3/21/19 Governor Newsom Proposing a Tax to Clean Up Drinking Water – KCBS – 3/22/19 Drinking Water Tax Proposed in California – CBS Sacramento – 3/20/19 Newsom Water Tax Offers a Phony Fix to a Moral Outrage – OC Register – 2/21/19 Inland Agencies Respond to Claims of Unsafe Tap Water: Clean Water for All Through Sound Planning and Investments – Press Enterprise – 2/10/19 2018 Coalition Letters Associations SB 845 Opposition Letter – Members of California Legislature – Aug. 23, 2018 ACWA’s SB 845 Coalition Memo – Members of California Legislature – Aug. 20, 2018 ACWA’s SB 623 Coalition Letter – Assembly Appropriations Committee – Updated Feb. 6, 2018 ACWA’s No Drinking Water Tax Oppose-Unless-Amended Coalition Letter – Budget Subcommittees – Updated June 19, 2018 Questions For media inquiries, please contact ACWA Director of Communications Heather Engel at (916) 441-4545. To learn more about the Safe Drinking Water Trust proposal or the proposed statewide water tax, please contact ACWA Deputy Executive Director for Government Relations Cindy Tuck at (916) 441-4545.