Proposed Drinking Water Tax Issue Heating Up with Statewide Media Coverage

  • by Timothy Quinn
  • Jun 4, 2018
  • Voices on Water

The vast majority of Californians have safe drinking water.  But some communities do not.  This is unacceptable, and it is an urgent social issue for the state.  Beginning last Friday online and published during this past weekend, The Sacramento Bee and four other affiliated newspapers throughout the state published stories that focused on the plight of 360,000 Californians without access to safe drinking water.  The stories presented this issue with the depth and seriousness it deserves as an urgent priority for our state.

Unfortunately, the stories misrepresented the diversity of ACWA’s membership and our position on funding solutions.  ACWA has 448 agricultural and urban public member agencies that deliver about 90% of the water used by households, farms, and businesses in California.  They are local governments; most with Boards of Directors elected by the public.  ACWA members have a direct relationship with their rate-paying customers.  The vast majority of our members are small and medium-sized agencies; it is simply not accurate to describe ACWA as representing “the big urban suppliers” referred to in the stories.  At present, 189 public water agencies and business associations, including many agricultural agencies throughout the state, have taken action to oppose the proposed water tax in the Brown Administration’s budget trailer bill, which is based on SB 623 (Monning).  They are not trying to “kill” the legislation as alleged in these articles.  Instead, they are trying to replace the proposed water tax with a reasonable funding mechanism so that legislation can be passed and the underlying drinking water problem in disadvantaged communities can be solved as soon as possible without an unnecessary tax on drinking water.

So, the controversy is not over whether or not there is a drinking water problem in certain communities.  Everyone involved in the legislation agrees that there is a problem that needs to be solved.  Everyone agrees that a Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Fund should be created.  The issue is what are the appropriate sources of funding, a topic largely ignored by the Bee articles.  The budget trailer bill would raise revenues through a new state tax on drinking water, something that is essential to life; a new state tax on a service that local agencies struggle to keep affordable; a new state tax to be paid by local household and business ratepayers that have no nexus whatever to the problem; a new state tax when the state has an $8.8 billion budget surplus – nearly 50% more than earlier projections.

Such a tax would set a precedent for additional new taxes on drinking water.  Two state agencies are already publicly discussing additional taxes on drinking water for various purposes.  If those taxes are approved, we would not be talking about 95 cents per household per month, but rather nearly $20 per month (and likely more) in state taxes added to local water bills.  If the Brown Administration succeeds in adding state taxes to local water bills to solve state social issues, they would crowd out the ability of local water agencies to do their job of raising funds to provide safe and reliable water supplies for their customers.  That outcome can be avoided because there are credible alternatives to a tax on water.

ACWA is not just asking that the state “explore“ alternatives as reported in the recent articles.  We are offering concrete proposals that rely on a variety of funding sources, including federal State Revolving Funds designed for this purpose, funds from general obligation bonds passed by the voters, nitrate-related fees on fertilizer sales, dairies and confined animal operations that are proposed in the budget trailer bill and SB 623, and a very modest use of the general fund to cover operation and maintenance costs.  The main objection to this alternative has been that the general fund is vulnerable to economic downturns.  We question which future Legislatures will not be able to commit $35 million in the annual budget for operation and maintenance costs if the issue is truly a priority for the state.

As another way to fund safe drinking water without a water tax, we are suggesting taking a small fraction of that $8.8 billion state budget surplus to create an irrevocable safe and affordable drinking water trust that could fund all or a portion of operation and maintenance costs into the future, including during down economic times.  Other alternatives are the use of lease revenue bonds and Cap-and-Trade funds.  (See WaterTaxFacts.org  for more information.) None of these practical, realistic and doable alternatives are mentioned in the story. Neither is it mentioned that ACWA would like nothing more than to reach an agreement on a funding alternative that ensures safe drinking water for all Californians.  The time is now for honest negotiation to develop viable funding alternatives to provide safe water for all Californians.

To learn more, visit ACWA’s No Water Tax page.

Suggested Resources

15 RESOURCES prev next
ACWA Statewide Reservoirs Mercury Control Program Technical Presentations Webinar

On May 30, 2018 ACWA hosted the Statewide Reservoirs Mercury Control Program Technical Presentations. This webinar highlighted state and local […]

Priority Issues Bulletin

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Joint Comments on State Water Board Electronic Annual Reporting

Submitted to the State Water Resources Control Board on May 30, 2018.

Comments on U.S. EPA Clean Water Act Coverage of “Discharges of Pollutants”

Submitted to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency on May 21, 2018.

ACWA 2018 Spring Conference Presentations

Presentations from ACWA’s 2018 Spring Conference & Exhibition held May 8-11 in Sacramento are available below. Please note that this […]

Joint Comments on the U.S. Forest Service’s Fiscal Year 2019 Budget

Submitted to U.S. Senators Lisa Murkoski and Maria Cantwell, Senate Committee on Energy & Natural Resources on May 8, 2018.

Federal Regulatory Chart

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

ACWA’S 2018 Spring LEGAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE CLE WORKSHOP MATERIALS

The following presentations and materials for ACWA’s 2018 Legal Affairs Committee CLE Workshop on May 8 from 9 a.m. to […]

2017 Year in Review

During 2017, ACWA and its membership proved how strength through collaboration can achieve goals unprecedented in terms of complexity and […]

No Water Tax Toolkit

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

2017 Summary of Legislation

ACWA’s 2017 Summary of Legislation provides concise information on legislation enacted in the first year of the 2017-’18 legislative session that […]

2017 Summary of Appellate Cases

ACWA’s  2017 Summary of Appellate Cases details court decisions in 2016-’17 that may be of interest to ACWA member agencies […]

Coalition Comments on Changes to Proposed Regulation Prohibiting Wasteful Water Use Practices

Submitted to the State Water Resources Control Board on Feb. 14, 2018.

Comments on Changes to Proposed Regulation Prohibiting Wasteful Water Use Practices

Submitted to the State Water Resources Control Board on Feb. 14, 2018.

2018 Federal Briefing Booklet

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Suggested News

15 Articles prev next
West Basin Municipal Water District Reaches Milestone of Producing 200 Billion Gallons of Recycled Water

Carson, Calif. – West Basin Municipal Water District (West Basin) is a wholesale water agency that provides imported drinking water […]

Reclamation updates 2018 Central Valley Project water allocations South-of-Delta

The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation on June 15 released the following statement regarding Central Valley Project water allocations. SACRAMENTO, Calif. […]

Faces of Water Q&A – June 2018

Telling the stories of the people who work to deliver California’s water… 1.) Describe your job. Padre Dam Municipal Water District […]

Member Case Study – June 2018

Nothing Goes to Waste in South Tahoe Public Utility District’s Wastewater Treatment Operation Everyone knows what runs downhill, but the […]

ACWA News: June 15, 2018

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Former Upper San Gabriel Valley MWD Director Royall Brown Passes Away

Monrovia, Calif. – Royall K. Brown, former Board Member for the Upper San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District (Upper District) […]

Three Inland Empire Students Recognized for Water is Life Artwork

Local students from Riverside County schools express water use efficiency through art Riverside, CA – Three students from Lakehills Elementary […]

Free Internet Access at PWD Extended To Assist Community

Palmdale, CA – The Palmdale Water District (PWD) Board of Directors voted Monday to increase the hours of free WiFi […]

ACWA Comments on Renewed Push for Statewide Water Tax

SACRAMENTO, CA – Timothy Quinn, executive director of the statewide Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA), issued the following statement […]

June Priority Issues Update Available to Members

The June 2018 Priority Issues Update is now available online to members. The update is bullet-style summary of the latest […]

Federal Legislation Introduced to Ensure Access to Affordable Clean Water for Working Families

U.S. Sen. Kamala D. Harris (D-Calif.) on June 6 introduced the Water Affordability Act of 2018, legislation that would help […]

SCWA Announces Student Winners in Annual Water Awareness Poster and Video Contests

Santa Rosa, CA – Winners of the Sonoma County Water Agency’s (Water Agency) annual Water Awareness school poster contest and […]

EMWD Recognized by J.D. Power for Customer Satisfaction

Perris, CA – Eastern Municipal Water District (EMWD) was recently honored with the prestigious J.D. Power and Associates award for […]

ACWA Comments on Passage of Proposition 68

SACRAMENTO, CA – Timothy Quinn, executive director of the statewide Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA), issued the following statement […]