Proposed Drinking Water Tax Issue Heating Up with Statewide Media Coverage

  • by Timothy Quinn
  • Jun 4, 2018
  • Voices on Water

The vast majority of Californians have safe drinking water.  But some communities do not.  This is unacceptable, and it is an urgent social issue for the state.  Beginning last Friday online and published during this past weekend, The Sacramento Bee and four other affiliated newspapers throughout the state published stories that focused on the plight of 360,000 Californians without access to safe drinking water.  The stories presented this issue with the depth and seriousness it deserves as an urgent priority for our state.

Unfortunately, the stories misrepresented the diversity of ACWA’s membership and our position on funding solutions.  ACWA has 448 agricultural and urban public member agencies that deliver about 90% of the water used by households, farms, and businesses in California.  They are local governments; most with Boards of Directors elected by the public.  ACWA members have a direct relationship with their rate-paying customers.  The vast majority of our members are small and medium-sized agencies; it is simply not accurate to describe ACWA as representing “the big urban suppliers” referred to in the stories.  At present, 189 public water agencies and business associations, including many agricultural agencies throughout the state, have taken action to oppose the proposed water tax in the Brown Administration’s budget trailer bill, which is based on SB 623 (Monning).  They are not trying to “kill” the legislation as alleged in these articles.  Instead, they are trying to replace the proposed water tax with a reasonable funding mechanism so that legislation can be passed and the underlying drinking water problem in disadvantaged communities can be solved as soon as possible without an unnecessary tax on drinking water.

So, the controversy is not over whether or not there is a drinking water problem in certain communities.  Everyone involved in the legislation agrees that there is a problem that needs to be solved.  Everyone agrees that a Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Fund should be created.  The issue is what are the appropriate sources of funding, a topic largely ignored by the Bee articles.  The budget trailer bill would raise revenues through a new state tax on drinking water, something that is essential to life; a new state tax on a service that local agencies struggle to keep affordable; a new state tax to be paid by local household and business ratepayers that have no nexus whatever to the problem; a new state tax when the state has an $8.8 billion budget surplus – nearly 50% more than earlier projections.

Such a tax would set a precedent for additional new taxes on drinking water.  Two state agencies are already publicly discussing additional taxes on drinking water for various purposes.  If those taxes are approved, we would not be talking about 95 cents per household per month, but rather nearly $20 per month (and likely more) in state taxes added to local water bills.  If the Brown Administration succeeds in adding state taxes to local water bills to solve state social issues, they would crowd out the ability of local water agencies to do their job of raising funds to provide safe and reliable water supplies for their customers.  That outcome can be avoided because there are credible alternatives to a tax on water.

ACWA is not just asking that the state “explore“ alternatives as reported in the recent articles.  We are offering concrete proposals that rely on a variety of funding sources, including federal State Revolving Funds designed for this purpose, funds from general obligation bonds passed by the voters, nitrate-related fees on fertilizer sales, dairies and confined animal operations that are proposed in the budget trailer bill and SB 623, and a very modest use of the general fund to cover operation and maintenance costs.  The main objection to this alternative has been that the general fund is vulnerable to economic downturns.  We question which future Legislatures will not be able to commit $35 million in the annual budget for operation and maintenance costs if the issue is truly a priority for the state.

As another way to fund safe drinking water without a water tax, we are suggesting taking a small fraction of that $8.8 billion state budget surplus to create an irrevocable safe and affordable drinking water trust that could fund all or a portion of operation and maintenance costs into the future, including during down economic times.  Other alternatives are the use of lease revenue bonds and Cap-and-Trade funds.  (See WaterTaxFacts.org  for more information.) None of these practical, realistic and doable alternatives are mentioned in the story. Neither is it mentioned that ACWA would like nothing more than to reach an agreement on a funding alternative that ensures safe drinking water for all Californians.  The time is now for honest negotiation to develop viable funding alternatives to provide safe water for all Californians.

To learn more, visit ACWA’s No Water Tax page.

Suggested Resources

15 RESOURCES prev next
Achieving Water Use Efficiency Through Water Loss Reduction

Achieving Water Use Efficiency Through Water Loss Reduction outlines the state’s process for developing water loss performance standards for urban retail […]

2020 PSPS Toolkit

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Webinar: COVID-19 Series – The Great Re-Set: Leading the Workplace Post COVID-19

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Comment Letter: Request for Water Infrastructure Funding in Future COVID-19 Legislation

To: Majority Leader McConnell, Minority Leader Schumer, Speaker Pelosi and Minority Leader McCarthy Subject: ACWA Request for Water Infrastructure Funding […]

Coalition Letter: Funding for Water Infrastructure and Water Affordability in Response to COVID-19

To: Speaker Pelosi, Minority Leader McCarthy, Senators Feinstein and Harris, and Members of the California Congressional Delegation Subject: Include Urgently […]

Comment Letter: Draft Fund Expenditure Plan for the Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Fund

Agency: State Water Resource Control Board Subject: Comment Letter – Draft Fund Expenditure Plan for the Safe and Affordable Drinking […]

Comment Letter: Water Loss Regulation

To: Ms. Jeanine Townsend Subject: Comment Letter – Water Loss Regulation Webinar Letter excerpt: The coalition of organizations listed below […]

Webinar: Geohazard Mitigation for California Water Agencies

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Coalition Letter: Regulation of PFOS, PFOA and other PFAS in Drinking Water

To: The Honorable Andrew Wheeler Subject: Regulation of PFOS, PFOA and other PFAS in drinking water Letter excerpt: We appreciate the […]

Comment Letter: Proposed Decision Adopting Additional and Modified De-Energization Guidelines

Agency: California Public Utilities Commission Subject: Joint Comments of Valley Center Municipal Water District, Padre Dam Municipal Water District, Municipal Water […]

Comment Letter: White Paper Discussion on Economic Feasibility Analysis in Consideration of a Hexavalent Chromium MCL

To: Jeanine Townsend, Clerk to the Board State Water Resources Control Board Subject: White Paper Discussion on Economic Feasibility Analysis […]

ACWA Submits Letters Urging State and Federal Leadership to Achieve Voluntary Agreements

To: Governor Newsom and U.S. Department of Interior Secretary Bernhardt Subject: Voluntary Agreements Description: ACWA urges Gov. Newsom and Secretary […]

Coalition Letter: Funding for Water Infrastructure & Affordability in Response to COVID-19 Pandemic

To: Speaker Pelosi, Minority Leader McCarthy and Members of the California Congressional Delegation: Subject: Include Urgently Needed Funding for Water […]

Webinar: How to Reduce Costs with PG&E’s New Time-of-Use (TOU) Rate Analysis

Sorry, but only ACWA members have permission to view this content. Member login is required.

Comment Letter: Draft Handbook for Water Budget Development

Agency: California Department of Water Resources Subject: Comment Letter on the ‘Draft Handbook for Water Budget Development: With or Without […]

Suggested News

15 Articles prev next
EMWD Honored for Financial Reporting Excellence

PERRIS — Eastern Municipal Water District (EMWD) was recently recognized for Excellence in Financial Reporting by the Government Finance Officers […]

Deadlines Approaching for ACWA’s 2020 Fall Awards

ACWA will present several awards at its 2020 Fall Conference & Exhibition, and the deadline to apply for two of […]

ACWA 2020 Summer Virtual Conference Materials Available Until Aug. 14

The materials for ACWA’s first-ever 2020 Summer Virtual Conference and Exhibition are available to conference attendees until Aug. 14. The […]

Fitch Ratings Upgrades San Juan Water District’s Credit Rating

GRANITE BAY – In July 2020, in spite of the economic challenges presented by the pandemic, Fitch Ratings Services upgraded […]

WRD Approves Construction of Two New Monitoring Wells

LAKEWOOD – The Water Replenishment District (WRD) is embarking on a project to construct two new wells as part of […]

Rowland Water Garners Statewide Spotlight for Customer Outreach

ROWLAND HEIGHTS – Rowland Water District is pleased to announce that it has received multiple honors in this year’s California […]

El Dorado Water Agency Launches New Brand

PLACERVILLE – The El Dorado Water Agency (formerly El Dorado County Water Agency) recently launched a new name and logo […]

ACWA Awards Scholarships to Four California College Students

SACRAMENTO – The Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA) has awarded $17,000 in scholarships to four undergraduate students enrolled at […]

Western Municipal Water District Announces 2020 Water is Life Art Contest Winners

RIVERSIDE – Each year, Western Municipal Water District (Western) hosts the annual Water is Life art contest for students in […]

Placer County Water Agency Receives 2020 Clair A. Hill Water Agency Award

SACRAMENTO – The Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA) today presented the prestigious Clair A. Hill Water Agency Award for […]

ACWA Presents Leadership Award to The Water Replenishment District GM Robb Whitaker

SACRAMENTO – The Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA) today presented its 2020 Excellence in Water Leadership Award to The […]

ACWA’s John P. Fraser Water Leaders Fellowship Awarded to Helen Rocha

SACRAMENTO – The Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA) today presented its first-ever John P. Fraser Water Leaders Fellowship to […]

State Releases Final Water Resilience Portfolio

SACRAMENTO – Gov. Gavin Newsom today released the final version of his Administration’s Water Resilience Portfolio, intended as a roadmap […]

Second Virtual Coffee with Palmdale Water District Directors

PALMDALE –  Two Palmdale Water District (PWD) Board Directors will hold individual Facebook Live events next week to continue honoring their […]

Yuba Water Advances Major Flood Risk Reduction Project

MARYSVILLE – Yuba Water Agency’s Board of Directors Thursday authorized staff to move forward with a new design of an […]